Defamation is the most common criminal complaint that leads nowhere. People confuse insult, criticism and defamation, and the police shelve most of it. But there is another side: a social media post that cost someone their job can be a crime, and on the internet the sentencing range is doubled.
When defamation is criminal
- An untrue statement of fact. Not an opinion, not an evaluation, not an insult. An assertion of fact that is not true. The Constitutional Court reminds us that the offender must know the statement is untrue, or at least be reconciled with that.
- Capable of seriously endangering someone's standing: harming them at work, disrupting family relationships, causing other serious harm. A trifle is not enough.
- A publicly accessible computer network (social media, websites) is the aggravated form: up to two years instead of one.
Subsidiarity
Criminal law is the last resort. In defamation cases both the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court say expressly that most disputes over reputation should be resolved by a civil action for the protection of personality rights, not by the police. For the accused, that is argument number one. For the injured party, it means that a criminal complaint without a clear untrue statement and without demonstrable harm will end up in a drawer, and that the better route is usually a civil court with a claim for an apology and damages.
What this rests on
No advice on this page is an opinion. Each one has a section of the law and a court decision behind it. Click through, the full text is on Europaius.
Statute
- § 184 tr. zákoníkudefamation: communicating an untrue statement capable of seriously endangering someone's standing; in print or on the internet, up to two years
- § 12 tr. zákoníkusubsidiarity of criminal repression
Case law
- III. ÚS 1459/22 (Ústavní soud, 9. 1. 2024)the offender must know the statement is untrue; "seriously endanger someone's standing" is interpreted with regard to the subsidiarity of criminal repression
- 3 Tdo 926/2024 (Nejvyšší soud, 27. 11. 2024)the elements of defamation including the aggravated form committed in print, on television or via a computer network
- 4 Tdo 734/2024 (Nejvyšší soud, 18. 9. 2024)defamation is a verbal offence; interpretation of the elements of an untrue statement and endangering someone's standing
A different situation?
- You or someone close to you has been detained
- Pre-trial detention is looming, or someone is already in it
- A police summons has arrived
- Criminal complaint: you want to file one, or one has been filed against you
- You have been charged with a criminal offence
- A penal order has arrived
- Alcohol or drugs behind the wheel, driving ban
- Plea agreement, conditional discontinuation
- House search
- You have become the victim of a crime
- European arrest warrant, extradition abroad
- Charged with embezzlement
- Disorderly conduct: a brawl, a pub, the street
- Dangerous threats and stalking
- You drove while banned from driving
- Charged with bodily harm
- Damage to property
- Violation of the inviolability of the home
- Conditional release from prison
- Negligent homicide: a fatal accident
- Credit fraud and subsidy fraud
